Review form for 2024-2025 residence grant applications_PhD Students

Name of reviewer: *

Laivnia FRANCESCONI, (PhD student)

Selection criterion 1: Motivation of the candidate (see in the application form: Why do you want to come to the IISL in Oñati?) *

Please assess in this section: ● Does the candidate give strong reasons for a research stay at the IISL? ● Is working at the library and in the community of other researchers a key motivation?

	1	2	3	4	5
Your score: (max. 5 points) *	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 1	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 2	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 3	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 4	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 5

Your comments: *

(In key words or bullet points)

Selection criterion 2: Quality of the research proposal (see the respective document in the application file) *

Please assess in this section: ● Does the research meaningfully contribute to socio-legal studies / sociology of law? ● Is the research proposal of good quality (taking academic age into account)?

	1	2	3	4	5
Your score: (max. 5 points) *	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 1	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 2	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 3	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 4	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 5

Your comments: *

(In key words or bullet points)

Selection criterion 3: Applicant's academic background and track-record (see CV in the application file) *

Please assess in this section: ● Does the applicant have a good track record so far (considering their career stage)? ● Does their academic background and prior work suggest a good match with the IISL?

	1	2	3	4	5
Your score: (max. 5 points) *	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 1	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 2	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 3	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 4	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 5

Your comments: *

(In key words or bullet points)

Selection criterion 4: Financial need (see country of origin/residence and any information on financial assistance and/or circumstances included in the application form) *

Please assess in this section: ● Does the applicant come from a country in Category C, ISA (as listed by the ISA? ● Are there other indicators of financial need that suggest a funding priority?

	1	2	3	4	5
Your score: (max. 5 points) *	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 1	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 2	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 3	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 4	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 5

Your comments: *

(In key words or bullet points)

Cristian HEREDIA LIGORRIA, (PhD student)

Selection criterion 1: Motivation of the candidate (see in the application form: Why do you want to come to the IISL in Oñati?) *

Please assess in this section: ● Does the candidate give strong reasons for a research stay at the IISL? ● Is working at the library and in the community of other researchers a key motivation?

	1	2	3	4	5
Your score: (max. 5 points) *	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 1	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 2	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 3	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 4	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 5

Your comments: *

(In key words or bullet points)

Selection criterion 2: Quality of the research proposal (see the respective document in the application file) *

Please assess in this section: ● Does the research meaningfully contribute to socio-legal studies / sociology of law? ● Is the research proposal of good quality (taking academic age into account)?

	1	2	3	4	5
Your score: (max. 5 points) *	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 1	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 2	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 3	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 4	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 5

Your comments: *

(In key words or bullet points)

Selection criterion 3: Applicant's academic background and track-record (see CV in the application file) *

Please assess in this section: ● Does the applicant have a good track record so far (considering their career stage)? ● Does their academic background and prior work suggest a good match with the IISL?

	1	2	3	4	5
Your score: (max. 5 points) *	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 1	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 2	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 3	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 4	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 5

Your comments: *

(In key words or bullet points)

Selection criterion 4: Financial need (see country of origin/residence and any information on financial assistance and/or circumstances included in the application form) *

Please assess in this section: ● Does the applicant come from a country in Category C, ISA (as listed by the ISA? ● Are there other indicators of financial need that suggest a funding priority?

	1	2	3	4	5
Your score: (max. 5 points) *	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 1	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 2	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 3	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 4	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 5

Your comments: *

(In key words or bullet points)

Danielle LUCKSTED, (PhD student)

Selection criterion 1: Motivation of the candidate (see in the application form: Why do you want to come to the IISL in Oñati?) *

Please assess in this section: ● Does the candidate give strong reasons for a research stay at the IISL? ● Is working at the library and in the community of other researchers a key motivation?

	1	2	3	4	5
Your score: (max. 5 points) *	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 1	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 2	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 3	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 4	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 5

Your comments: *

(In key words or bullet points)

Selection criterion 2: Quality of the research proposal (see the respective document in the application file) *

Please assess in this section: ● Does the research meaningfully contribute to socio-legal studies / sociology of law? ● Is the research proposal of good quality (taking academic age into account)?

	1	2	3	4	5
Your score: (max. 5 points) *	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 1	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 2	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 3	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 4	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 5

Your comments: *

(In key words or bullet points)

Selection criterion 3: Applicant's academic background and track-record (see CV in the application file) *

Please assess in this section: ● Does the applicant have a good track record so far (considering their career stage)? ● Does their academic background and prior work suggest a good match with the IISL?

	1	2	3	4	5
Your score: (max. 5 points) *	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 1	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 2	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 3	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 4	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 5

Your comments: *

(In key words or bullet points)

Selection criterion 4: Financial need (see country of origin/residence and any information on financial assistance and/or circumstances included in the application form) *

Please assess in this section: ● Does the applicant come from a country in Category C, ISA (as listed by the ISA? ● Are there other indicators of financial need that suggest a funding priority?

	1	2	3	4	5
Your score: (max. 5 points) *	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 1	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 2	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 3	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 4	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 5

Your comments: *

(In key words or bullet points)

Diego RUEDAS TORRES, (PhD student)

Selection criterion 1: Motivation of the candidate (see in the application form: Why do you want to come to the IISL in Oñati?) *

Please assess in this section: ● Does the candidate give strong reasons for a research stay at the IISL? ● Is working at the library and in the community of other researchers a key motivation?

	1	2	3	4	5
Your score: (max. 5 points) *	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 1	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 2	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 3	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 4	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 5

Your comments: *

(In key words or bullet points)

Selection criterion 2: Quality of the research proposal (see the respective document in the application file) *

Please assess in this section: ● Does the research meaningfully contribute to socio-legal studies / sociology of law? ● Is the research proposal of good quality (taking academic age into account)?

	1	2	3	4	5
Your score: (max. 5 points) *	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 1	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 2	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 3	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 4	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 5

Your comments: *

(In key words or bullet points)

Selection criterion 3: Applicant's academic background and track-record (see CV in the application file) *

Please assess in this section: ● Does the applicant have a good track record so far (considering their career stage)? ● Does their academic background and prior work suggest a good match with the IISL?

	1	2	3	4	5
Your score: (max. 5 points) *	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 1	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 2	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 3	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 4	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 5

Your comments: *

(In key words or bullet points)

Selection criterion 4: Financial need (see country of origin/residence and any information on financial assistance and/or circumstances included in the application form) *

Please assess in this section: ● Does the applicant come from a country in Category C, ISA (as listed by the ISA? ● Are there other indicators of financial need that suggest a funding priority?

	1	2	3	4	5
Your score: (max. 5 points) *	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 1	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 2	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 3	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 4	Your score: (max. 5 points) - 5

Your comments: *

(In key words or bullet points)

Overall scoring: *

Considering my above scores and comments for the applications I was assigned to review, I arrive at the following ranking of the selected applications:

	A (best)	B (medium)	C (lowest)
Laivnia FRANCESCONI *	Laivnia FRANCESCONI - A (best)	Laivnia FRANCESCONI - B (medium)	Laivnia FRANCESCONI - C (lowest)
Cristian HEREDIA LIGORRIA *	Cristian HEREDIA LIGORRIA - A (best)	Cristian HEREDIA LIGORRIA - B (medium)	Cristian HEREDIA LIGORRIA - C (lowest)
Danielle LUCKSTED *	Danielle LUCKSTED - A (best)	Danielle LUCKSTED - B (medium)	Danielle LUCKSTED - C (lowest)
Diego RUEDAS TORRES *	Diego RUEDAS TORRES - A (best)	Diego RUEDAS TORRES - B (medium)	Diego RUEDAS TORRES - C (lowest)

I authorize the IISL to process my assessment information: *

I authorize the Institute to use the information on the evaluation of applications for the evaluation of proposals received and only for that purpose.

YES

NO

Sending date:

Month

Day

Year

CAPTCHA

This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Math question * 3 + 1 =

More information?

For more information:

Workshop Coordination Team

Avenida de la Universidad, 8
Apartado 28
20560 Oñati (Gipuzkoa) - Spain
T: +34 943 78... Ver teléfono
E: workshop@iisj.es

Oñati International Institute for the Sociology of Law

Avenida Universidad 8 - Apartado 28
20560 Oñati (Gipuzkoa)
Spain

Support the IISL

The Institute has received many generous individual donations for a number of years.

Make a donation